Orange County NC Website
Browse       Search
<br /> <br /> <br />Evidence submitted by the county representative: <br />• The subject property is a 3,432 square foot single family home with 5 bedrooms, 3 and 1/2 <br />baths on 6.35 acres located at 910 Old Orchard Road in Chapel Hill. <br />• The subject property sold with another property in May 2025 for $1,145,000 and an appraisal <br />was done for the lender at the time of the sale recommending a value of $1,030,000. Both the <br />sale and the appraisal are outside the scope of the revaluation dates. <br />• Based on physical attributes of the property, The County recommends: <br />*adding an adjustment to the land of -30% for topography and shape <br />*correcting the bath count to 3 full and 2 half baths <br />*correcting the fireplace count from 2 to 3 <br />The recommended adjustments would result in a revised value from $995,900 to $855,700. <br />• Photo of subject <br />• GIS Map <br />• Sales and Equity Analysis <br />• Current Property Record Card <br />• Proposed Property Record Card <br /> <br /> <br />Motion of the Board Accept County's Proposed Value: $855,700 <br />Made the motion Saru Salvi <br />Seconded the motion Richal Vanhook <br />Voted For All BOER Members ... <br />Voted Against ... ... <br /> <br /> <br />Property Identification: <br /> <br />Property Owner Heman H. Robinson III Appellant (if different) <br />Property Address 1017 Starfield Circle Parcel ID or Abstract 9862904836 <br /> <br />Statement of Appeal: Request a reduction in value based on incorrect data on the current property record <br />card and on comparable sales. <br /> <br />Current Assessed Value $838,200 County Opinion $838,200 <br />Time of Hearing 2:03PM Appellant Opinion $750,000 <br />County Representative Louise Benson- <br />Lochner <br />Board Decision $780,200 <br /> <br />Evidence submitted by the appellant: <br />• The appellant filed a formal appeal on May 6, 2025. <br />• The appellant: <br />Supplied an MLS listing of the subject from 2010 notating the finished living area is <br />2813square feet. <br />Supplied a Comper report with 2 comparable sales. <br />• No additional evidence e.g. photos, repair bids, comparable sales were provided. <br /> <br /> <br />Evidence submitted by the county representative: <br />Docusign Envelope ID: 9059FA55-A276-4268-BB65-E0BF0D9AD45E