Orange County NC Website
Browse       Search
<br /> <br /> <br />Current Assessed Value $1,194,500 County Opinion $1,154,500 <br />Time of Hearing 4:40PM Appellant Opinion $954,120 <br />County Representative Heidi Whetzel Board Decision $1,154,500 <br /> <br />Evidence submitted by the appellant: <br />• 4 comparable properties all have lower per square foot values. <br /> <br /> <br />Evidence submitted by the county representative: <br />• The subject property is located at 705 Coker Lane in Chapel Hill. A site visit was conducted on <br />October 23, 2025, and a hang tag was left to notify the appellant of the visit. After completing <br />a sales analysis, it was found that comparable sales in the area are limited. Many of the <br />surrounding properties are smaller in size and older than the subject dwelling. The comparable <br />sales submitted by the appellant are approximately 50 years older and notably smaller. The <br />comparable sales utilized in the County’s analysis are closer in age to the subject property; <br />however, those properties are of higher construction grade. Additionally, a review of aerial <br />imagery in GIS indicates a stream running along the rear portion of the parcel. <br />• After review, the County recommends the following change: <br />• Applying a -10% adjustment for topography. <br />• This adjustment will result in a revised value from $1,194,500 to $1,154,500. <br />• Photos of Subject <br />• Current Property Record Card <br />• Proposed Property Record Card <br />• Sales Analysis <br />• Comp photos listed in the analysis <br />• GIS Map <br /> <br /> <br />Motion of the Board Accept County's Proposed Value: $1,154,500 <br />Made the motion Richal Vanhook <br />Seconded the motion Saru Salvi <br />Voted For All BOER Members ... <br />Voted Against ... ... <br /> <br /> <br />Property Identification: <br /> <br />Property Owner Shayna Hill Appellant (if different) Donald Burke <br />Property Address 410 Brookside Drive Parcel ID or Abstract 9788240329 <br /> <br />Statement of Appeal: Request a reduction in value based on the age and condition of the home. <br /> <br />Current Assessed Value $936,900 County Opinion $830,600 <br />Time of Hearing 4:53PM Appellant Opinion $675,000 <br />County Representative Dana Hall Board Decision $780,600 <br /> <br />Evidence submitted by the appellant: <br />Docusign Envelope ID: 9059FA55-A276-4268-BB65-E0BF0D9AD45E