Agenda - 09-06-2022; 8-a - Minutes

Browse Search

14 1 Such an ordinance may only be adopted at the next regular meeting following its introduction. 2 Because one potential penalty of this ordinance is trespass, which is a statutory misdemeanor, 3 this ordinance may only be adopted at its second reading. First reading for this proposed 4 ordinance occurred at the Board's June 7, 2022 Business meeting. 5 6 John Roberts said this is the fifth time this has been on an agenda for the Board to 7 discuss. He said that each time it has gotten smaller, and he recommends that it get a bit 8 smaller tonight. He said it would prohibit protests on school property when there are students 9 present for any purpose. He said that there are three types of public forum as it relates to 10 government property. He said the traditional public forum, limited public forum, and nonpublic 11 forum are the types. He said that in a traditional public forum, the government may not regulate 12 speech and gave the example that the courthouse steps or the lawn around the courthouse 13 would be places where speech could not be regulated. He said that a limited public forum is a 14 government property that has been specifically designated for freedom of expression but is 15 subject to certain kinds of limitation, either time, place, and manner, or event content, but it has 16 to be very narrow. He said that the Eno Arts Mill would be an example of this type of property 17 with artists having political works. He said that a non-public forum is something that is not 18 traditional or limited, or a designated area. He said that an example would be government 19 offices, the jail, public schools, and things like that. He said that the Supreme Court has said 20 that a government may place limits on spaces that are non-public forums, which is what school 21 properties are. 22 Chair Price said she should have prefaced this by saying that this was brought to the 23 Board by residents, so the Board is responding to those concerns. 24 John Roberts said that the recommendation for a change with the words "vigil" and 25 "observation." He said those were left over from sample ordinances from other jurisdictions but 26 does not fit the legal definition for the use of those words. He said that his recommendation is to 27 change the definition of picketer/picketing to the activity or circumstance whereby one or more 28 persons gather together for a common purpose for a protest or demonstration which primarily 29 promotes or objects to a person, policy, political candidate issue or action. He said that is the 30 only specific change that he recommended. He said that he notified the Board earlier that when 31 he was reviewing other buffer regulations that the county has developed by ordinance that the 32 1,000 feet that was requested by the school board does seem extremely lengthy. He said that 33 the next closest buffer regulation is 150 yards or 450 feet. He recommended the Board consider 34 another distance. 35 Chair Price said she received an email from Patrick Abele, and he said 1,000 feet is the 36 distance for registered sex offenders. 37 Commissioner McKee said going back to the definition, one person may be considered a 38 picketer. 39 John Roberts said it could be. He said that there was originally a minimum number and 40 the Board discussed that a minimum was not needed. 41 Commissioner McKee said that "any common purpose" is pretty broad. He said that 42 removing "vigil" and "observation" leaves protest, demonstrations, or other action. He said that 43 his other issue is with "or other action." He asked the attorney to define "other action." 44 John Roberts said he removed that in his recommendation because it was subjective. 45 Commissioner Greene said that she does not see the new recommendation in the 46 attorney portal or the other email. 47 John Roberts said that the recommendation is what he just read and that he sent an 48 email that contained the language. 49 PUBLIC COMMENTS: 50 Dale Hodson asked if the Board would be voting on an item that the public has not seen.