Minutes - 20050831 - Laserfiche WebLink

Browse Search

to Board to re-consider this option. As to the Board of County Commissioners' concern about diluting the African-American vote and making it more difficult for African- Americans to be elected to the Orange County Board she said their concern is heard. However, as all of them know the northern Orange Black Voter's Alliance openly supported Representative Faisan's plan. Also, she expressed her concern about being asked to talk about proposals that do not include district lines. She requested another series of public hearings be held after lines are drawn. David Lewis is from Chapel Hill Township and has lived there for 30 years and now he and his wife are building on Arthur Minnis Road, which is still in the same voting precinct. Both he and his wife would like to see some change in voting methods with more representation from individuals who have similar backgrounds to theirs. Dolly Hunter lives in Bingham Township and she has worked on The Rural Character Study Committee, The Agricultural Preservation Board, and has followed closely all the different zoning changes and subdivision regulations. She has stayed pretty familiar with the changes during the last 24 years. The rural residents are asking for district eating not to take any power away from Chapel Hill or the southern part of the County but to have someone sitting at the table representing the northern residents' concerns. It is the rural people who made this County what it is and they deserve a voice in what happens to it. All of the decisions that the Board of County Commissioners makes affect all equally except land use. The current elections system allows the County Commissioners to make decisions about land use without needing to be responsive to the rural residents that own the land. She asked that in designing the options that the decisions be made by a committee with rural representation. Pearson Stewart lives in Chapel Hill Township and he supports the principle of district representation. He acknowledges and concurs with the desirability of one person, one vote and also agrees with the desirability of as much local Commissioner contact with the community as is possible. Both of these are desirable, but putting them together in Orange County is very difficult. The best way of putting these two principles together is to enlarge the Board of Commissioners by about 15 to 25 people. That would do the job and would also cause all sorts of other problems. He supports the enlargement of the board to 7 members and the idea that both rural and urban people are capable people and are capable of considering the needs of Orange County as a whole. Concerning the question about whether at-large representation is necessary he submits that good district representation is sufficient and without at-large representation will give you that much more flexibility in coming up with a good solution. Artie Franklin lives in Chapel Hill Township and seven days ago he discussed proportional representation as a comprehensive and long term solution in contrast to the three options offered. At that public hearing County Attorney Geof Gledhill advised that implementing proportional representation would require legislative approval. The requirement of legislative approval transforms proportional representation into a solution of tomorrow. Under-representation in Orange County is a problem of today and solutions offered today are three options that share district resident primaries combined with at-large general elections. Of the three, he prefers Option #2 which provides 5 district resident commissioners and 2 county resident commissioners. While all three options provide relief to the under-represented who live in the rural districts, the problem of under-representation is not limited to those who live in the rural county. Option #2 provides representation to members of the communities who live close together as in districts as well as to the members of communities who live apart. Options 1 and 3 potentially deny both like-minded individuals who live in different districts and those with a countywide perspective to elect commissioners responsible for