Minutes - 19990209 - Laserfiche WebLink

Browse Search

--- ._ _ � \ �'�° � \ � z' 3" i' � 5 1 2 Commissioner Brown asked Mr. Scarola to explain what benefit it was to Orange County citizens to 3 have more storage at Shearon Harris. Scarola stated that risk is something that they look at on a day- � ' to-day basis. They are going to move the same number of fuel bundles on a given day now as is ,, proposed to be moved ten years from now. The only thing that will change is the storage capaciry. 6 The analysis that has been done on this plant has stated that it is "Beyond Design Basis." That 7 means that there is not a credible scenario that they have been able to develop that would lead to that 8 event. He stated that there is no increased risk. 9 . 10 Commissioner Carey mentioned that he has received several questions regarding what source of 11 money the County is using to pursue this endeavor. He clarified that the Commissioners are using 12 taxpayer money because the Board of County Commissioners is responsible for protecting the 13 public's interest. This is an effort to get information out to the pubiic so that the public can make 14 informed decisions. 15 16 Commissioner Carey asked about the issue of unreviewed safety questions that Dr. Thompson raised 17 in his presentation. 18 , 19 Mr. Scarola first referred back to the comments about the N advertisement and stated that CP&L did 20 not run the N advertisements in question. With regard to the "unreviewed safety questions", Scarola 21 said that he had not seen that information before today. The license proposal that goes to the NRC 22 with the comment"Unreviewed Safety Questions" does not mean that it has not been analyzed. Each 23 issue is analyzed. Some of the scenarios that were presented were not analyzed because they have 24 not been deemed credible events in the industry and therefore are not required to be analyzed. 25 26 Citizen Question: Why can the Robinson Plant not continue to store its spent fuel in its dry storage ''� facilities? Isn't it primarily an issue of cost in deciding to ship to Shearon Harris? Mr. Scarola stated ( that after the initial safety review, then economics is factored into their decisions. They are required to �9 provide cost efficient service. It is much more expensive to provide dry storage. 30 31 Citizen Question: What are the safety consequences of recent staff reductions at the Shearon Harris 32 plant? Which safety related positions were eliminated? Mr. Scarola stated that there have been no 33 staff reductions since he began at the facility in August 1998. Throughout the industry there is a drive 34 toward more efficient operations and computer systems have been implemented that have taken over 35 manual operations. 36 37 Citizen Question: With reference to fire hazards there were several questions. One was with regard 38 to the minimum cooling time to avoid fire hazard in a partially drained fuel pool. Another question � 39 asked if fire hazard was used as a basis for prior interventions and what had been the result. Finally, 40 there was a question about the pool building leaking radiation if there was an accident. 41 42 Jim Scarola stated that the component cooling water capacity was sufficient for the initial racking 43 needed to put the "C" pool into service. CP&L has told the NRC that they have a limit that they would 44 not go over before reanalyzing and addressing additional component cooling water capability. With 45 regard to the implications of an off-site accident, he emphasized that the work that has been done is 46 far"Beyond Design Basis" events which means that they have not come up with a credible scenario 47 that could lead to an event causing an off-site accident. However, the C & D pools will have fuel that 48 has cooled down and the analysis shows that fuel that is greater than 17 months old does not pose an 49 off-site hazard by the possible drain-down of that pool. 50 � Dr. Thompson said that when the nuclear industry was established in this country, initially the _t spectrum of accidents was defined in such as way as to encompass all credible events. It was 53 subsequently realized that there were other possible accidents beyond the design basis. 54 Furthermore, the NRC requires all of its licensees to conduct an "integrated plant examination"which